Diatoms in lung tissue: first investigation in Brazil in proving death by drowning

Resumo

Diatoms are microalgae widely distributed in inland and marine waters and during drowning they are inhaled together with water, passing through the bloodstream to various internal organs of a victim. Our investigation aimed to evaluate the diatoms extracted from the lung tissues of an individual with drowning diagnosis and compare them to those found in the environment, in order to prove the cause of death and the drowning site. A left lung fragment of 17.9 grams removed from the victim was oxidized and prepared for diatoms identification and quantification using inverted microscope. A total of 133 diatoms valves was found, being 85% belong to pennate forms and 15% to centric forms. Pinnularia, a bentonic genus, had greatest number of valves, followed by Fragilaria, Actinocyclus, Cocconeis and Encyonema. These results revealed that the victim drowned at the bottom of the lake, inhaling both water and sediments with diatoms. This is the first investigation of this nature carried out in Brazil.

Referências

  1. V. Revenstorf. Der Nachsweis der aspirierten Ertränkungflussigkeit als Kriterium des Todes durch Ertrinken. Vjschr gerichtl Med. 27, 274-299, 1904.
  2. B. Mueller. Zur Frage der Diagnostik des Ertrinkungstodes. Dtsch Z. gerichtl Med. 41, 400-404, 1952.
  3. F. Thomas; W. Van Hecke; J. Timperman. The Detection of Diatoms in the Bone Marrow as Evidence of Death by Drowning. J. Forensic Med. 8(3), 142-144, 1961.
  4. F. Thomas; W. Van Hecke; J. Timperman. Diagnostic médico-légal de la mort par submersion par la mise en évidence de diatomées dans la moelle des os longs. Ann. Méd. lég. 42(4), 1-7, 1962.
  5. F. Thomas; W. Van Hecke; J. Timperman. The Mediocolegal Diagnosis od Deadth by drowning. J. Forensic Sci. 8(1), 1-14, 1963.
  6. J. Timperman. The detection of Diatoms in the Marrow of the Sternum. J. Forensic Med. 9(4),134-136, 1962.
  7. J. Timperman. Medico-Legal Problems in Death by Drowning. J. Forensic Med. 16(2), 45-75, 1969.
  8. B. Ludes; M. Coste. Diatomées et medicine légale. Tec & Doc Lavoisier, Paris, p. 115-120, 1996.
  9. A. J. Peabody. Diatoms and Drowning - A Review. Med. Sci. Law. 20(4), 254-261, 1980.
  10. N. N. I. Maidana. El uso de las diatomeas en la medicina forense en Argentina. Anais do 57º Congresso Nacional de Botânica. p. 258-260, 2006.
  11. N. I. Maidana. El test de diatomeas em el diagnóstico de muerte por sumersión. Acta Nova 6(1-2), 70-81, 2013.
  12. M. Ming; X. Meng; E. Wang. Evaluation of four digestive methods for extracting diatom. Forensic Sci. Int. 170(1), 29-34, 2007.
  13. S. Hu; C. Liu; J. Wen; W. Dai; S. Wang; H. Su; J. Zhao J. Detection of diatoms in water and tissues by combination of microwave digestion, vacum filtration and scanning electron microscopy. Forensic Sci. Int. 226, 48-51, 2013.
  14. N. Fucci. A New Procedure for Diatom Extraction in the Diagnosis of Drowning. Clin Exp Pharmacol 2(2), 1-2, 2012.
  15. L. Donadel; N. Cardoso; A. Hoenisch; L.R.P. Utz. Revisão sobre o diagnóstico de afogamento com o uso do plankton, teste de diatomáceas e de PCR. Rev. Bras. Crimin. 3(2), 17-23, 2014.
  16. R. Singh; R. Kaur. Diatomological mapping of water bodies - A future perspective. J. Forensic Leg. Med. 20, 622-625, 2013.
  17. J. Zhao; Y. Wangb; Y. Zhangc; S. Hua; C. Liu. Types of diatoms in China’s three major rivers and the possible application for an automatic forensic diatom test. Austr. J. Forensic Sci. 47(3), 268-274, 2005.
  18. A.J.Peabody. Diatoms and Drowning- A Review. Med Sci Law 20(4), 254-261, 1980.
  19. J.C.M. Macchiavello. Aplicación de las Diatomeas en Medicina Forense. Contribuciones en Diatomología 1, 1-8, 2003.
  20. S. Krstic; A. Duma; B. Janevska; Z. Levkov; K. Nikolova; M. Noveska. Diatoms in forensic expertise of drowning - a Macedonian experience. Forensic Sci Int. 127, 198-203, 2002.
  21. F.E. Round; R.M. Crawford; D.G. Mann. The diatoms. Biology & Morphology of the genera. Cambridhe Univesity Press, Cambridge p. 556, 1990.
  22. L.C. Torgan; L.W. Aguiar Diatomáceas do “rio” Guaíba, Porto Alegre, Rio Grande do Sul, Brasil. Iheringia, Sér. Bot. 23, 19-63, 1978.
  23. S.E. Salomoni; L.C. Torgan. Epilithic diatoms as organic contamination degree indicators in Guaiba lake, Southern Brazil. Acta Limnol. Bras. 20(4), 313-324, 2008.
  24. L.C.Torgan; S.E. Salomoni; A.B.Bicca. Diatomáceas sobre Limnoperna fortunei Drunker molusco introduzido no Lago Guaíba, sul do Brasil. Rev. Bras. Bot. 32(1), 23-31, 2009.
  25. L.Martau; L.W. Aguiar; V.L.M. Callegaro Diatomáceas do rio dos Sinos, Rio Grande do Sul. Iheringia, Sér. Bot. 22, 45-83, 1977.
  26. D. Bes; L.Ector; L.C. Torgan; E.A. Lobo Composition of the epilithic diatom flora from subtropical river, Southern Brazil. Iheringia, Sér. Bot. 67(1), 93-125, 2012.
  27. M. Laux; L.C. Torgan. Diatomáceas com plastídeos no plâncton da foz dos rios do Delta do Jacuí, sul do Brasil, um complemento a taxonomia tradicional. Iheringia, Sér. Bot. 66(1), 109-132, 2011.
  28. B. Lulodes; M. Coste; N. North; S. Doray; A. Tracqui Diatom analysis in victim´s tissues as an indicator of the site of drowning. Int. J. Legal Med. 112, 163-166, 1999.
Creative Commons License

Este trabalho está licenciado sob uma licença Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Copyright (c) 2017 Revista Brasileira de Criminalística

Compartilhe

Download

PDF (English)

Autor(es)